Massive Conflict of Interest and Data Distortion Little Known
"Diagnosisgate" — It is probably the most stunning story of corruption in the history of the modern mental-health system. Mysteriously, it has been kept out of major media for two decades.
In recent years, the man who has been called the world's most important psychiatrist has painted himself as the white knight who warns the public about the dangers of Big Pharma and psychiatric diagnosis. But Allen Frances, the longest-running head of psychiatry's "bible," the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders — which earned more than $100 million under his reign — actually worked hand-in-glove with a major drug company to misrepresent research on a massive scale in order to market misleadingly one of their most dangerous drugs, Risperdal.
Nearly a year ago, my attention was drawn to a blockbuster of a document that revealed these distortions of science and the whopping conflicts of interest. It was essential to inform the public, because it is the mental health system's Watergate and has led to enormous harm. One editor after another of both general publications and scholarly journals fled from publishing the story. This surprised me, given the story's importance and the fact that it was almost completely unknown to the public and professionals.
The brave Dr. David Holmes, editor of the journal APORIA, based at the University of Ottawa, has just published the article, which is at http://www.oa.uottawa.ca/journals/aporia/articles/2015_01/commentary.pdf
This sequence of events tragically affects vast numbers of people ... two enormous groups are military servicemembers and veterans (though by no means only them). Have a look at this quotation from http://www.nextgov.com/defense/2012/04/broken-warriors-test/55389/ :
"Veterans Affairs Department reported in August 2011 that Risperidone was no more effective in PTSD treatment than a placebo. VA spent $717 million on the drug over the past decade. The military has spent $74 million over the past 10 years on Risperidone, a spokeswoman for the Defense Logistics Agency said."
So many people whose lives were harmed because of being psychiatrically labeled, given psychiatric drugs that had adverse effects, or both could have been spared enormous suffering if they had known this story.
©copyright 2015 by Paula J. Caplan All rights reserved